Comments

What’s the Easiest Shape to Build? — 26 Comments

  1. Hi Dr. Owen, please can you help me? I want a round house but am confused about bag size. My plan is for a 20ft roundhouse and I guess the walls should be 18inches thick. Should I buy 20inch bags or 22inch? On YouTube you say you use 18inch bags. have a few friends helping me (carpenter and electrician)

  2. Pingback:Fabric Forming « Geopolymer House Blog

  3. Pingback:Three Roundhouses Design « Earthbag House Plans

  4. Why use poly bags when you can just ram the earth? Is it just about labour reduction and being clever? Can you use any clayey sub soil? Do these building perform better in certain environments?

    • Rammed earth requires expensive forms that are only practical for contractors who use them repeatedly. Homeowners can build their own home with earthbags without contractors or forms.

      Yes, almost any clayey subsoil will work. You want enough clay to bind the sand and gravel together. Make a test bag and see if it dries really hard.

      Earthbag will work in any climate if designed correctly. It’s best where there are few building codes. Building codes will greatly increase the cost of construction.

  5. The briefings comment say 15:th will they announce.
    *******
    So the final date for the announcement of the winners has been set at June 15.
    The judges and I hope and thank you for your understanding and we look forward to sharing the results with everyone on that date!
    *******

  6. why use plastic bags when you can just ram the earth? is it just about saving labour and being able ti use any old earth instead of decent clayey sub soil? Do these buildings work better in certain environments?

    • Earthbags (bags and tubes) serve as flexible forms that can create almost any shape building. Wooden forms are expensive. Rammed earth requires a fairly specific formula. Earthbag building offers a whole range of benefits (few tools required, relatively simple construction, no specific soil, etc.).

  7. It is also a question of what is easier to live in. For example, kitchen cabinet units are rectangular, not round. So are beds, and bathtubs, and tables, chairs, sofas, shelves, etc.

    For a round house, you basically have to custom make a lot of the furniture if you want it against the wall, which raises the cost considerably.

    One issue with earthbags is that building long straight walls are unstable. That means buttressing and wall bracing, which ads to the complexity (and cost) of construction.

    I’m not sure how long of a straight wall could be made without some sort of bracing, but I imagine 3-4m. So, that means every 3-4m you need either a buttress or wall intersection. I guess you could possibly do a pilaster, maybe reinforced concrete every 3m or so as well. A poured column on the inside and outside of the wall, maybe 8″ thick would stiffen it considerably.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>